Punishment must fit the crime

It is important for employers to remember when managing misconduct issues to ensure that the punishment fits the crime.

For example in the case of In Beamish v Calvary Health Care Tasmania Limited T/A Calvary Health Care Tasmania [2016] a matter involving the alleged misuse of internal communication a terminated employee was reinstated after it was found by the FWC that a reference to the Director of the Catholic Mission as “Mission Impossible” in internal emails was a misguided attempt at humour and not sufficiently serious to warrant termination.

The Fair Work Commission ordered the reinstatement after finding that “the punishment did not fit the crime”.

It is often the case that employers are unsure as to what course of action to take when dealing with misconduct, I advise the following;

  • Investigate the matter thoroughly ensuring that you gather and consider all the available evidence.
  • Ensure that you always afford the person subject of the complaint procedural fairness, the right to know what they are being accused of and the right that their response is heard and considered.
  • Take into account
    • o The nature and overall effect of the misconduct to the parties and to the organisation
    • o The employees history, length of time with the organisation and previous if any misconduct issues
  • Review options other than termination

Still not sure, contact AWPTI, we can take the stress out of dealing with misconduct issues for you.

AWPTI – workplace investigations in Sydney and through-out NSW, QLD and Victoria. Workplace training national wide
Workplace investigations misconduct, bullying, harassment & sexual harassment investigations


The author Phil O’Brien is a highly experienced and skilled workplace investigator and trainer who can take the stress out of conducting workplace investigations into bullying, harassment, sexual harassment, discrimination and other forms of misconduct.

You can contact me on 02 9674 4279 or phil@awpti.com.au

This is general information only. It does not replace advice from a qualified workplace investigator in your state or territory.  It is recommended that should you encounter complaints in the workplace that you seek advice from suitability qualified and experienced workplace investigators.





0 replies

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.